1. All my “relatives” crying:
I couldn’t understand why in the hell were people who barely knew my father were crying loudly and profusely, whereas my bro, sis and I were not crying that much. I even went to take a nap and had food all three times of the day, whereas some of the people I have mentioned above ate very little food or completely refrained from eating food. What’s the point in not eating food? I don’t get it. Is the dead person going to come back to life if you don’t eat food?? The most funniest thing: here were the three people most closely related to deceased person going and consoling people who were distantly related to deceased.
I couldn’t understand why were people whom my father barely knew so worked up over his death. Then me friend told me: Most people cry at funeral whether they feel like it or not, because they think they are supposed to cry at funerals. It’s a sort of peer pressure thing. “People will think badly about me if i don’t cry at funerals” has been etched into the minds of people and they blindly follow it.
Also, people who were crying were uttering the following phrases to my father’s corpse. C’mon people, what’s the point in talking to a dead body? How can a dead person hear to what you are talking? And I am called insane!! Anyway, these phrases made me laugh. Some of the phrases were:
· “Why did you leave us and go? How did you have the heart to do this?”
Yeah, Right! Why would any sane person in his/her right mind voluntarily die? That too when they have many loved ones?? Some people actually scold the dead person for dying!!! I cannot still fathom till date why people behave that way in funerals.
· “Please open your eyes and look at me/us once.”
This is one seriously is the most funniest. I mean the person is dead, how would he/she open their eyes?? I wonder how many of them would not scream and run away or go mad, if a dead person opens his/her eyes?
Now, here are some questions.
a) According to most theist, when a person dies they go to heaven or hell depending upon whether they were a good person or a bad person. Now, most theists will claim heaven is a better place than the earth and etc etc. Now, I see that people cry at the funeral of everyone. The question is: So, is no one going to heaven, because everyone was a bad person or is that no one is happy that a person they know going to heaven??Answer this one theist!
b) Once a person dies, we start referring to the person’s body as it. Until that time, we refer to a person’s body as he/she. Why this disrespect? So, you guys mean to say that the body of a person has no relevance? If so, why then are people crying when only body has expired? Doesn’t a person still continue to live on?
c) Why at all do people cry at funerals? Just because a person dies does is it man that person is dead? I mean, physically that person is dead. But, doesn’t that person continue to live on in our memories and hearts?? It disgusts me that people seem to give so much importance to flesh and bones than to the person. After all a person is more than just flesh and bones. Isn’t a person also the ideals, values, and beliefs that were held by that person, the actions that the persons committed during his/her lifetime?
2. No Television:
This happened a couple of days (Some 4-5 days.) after my father’s death. One of my younger cousins wanted to watch that day’s IPL match. So, I was connecting the TV wires and was switching it on, when one of my aunts comes and says “No, No, you should not watch TV n all.” I was like “Huh!! Why can’t/shouldn’t I watch TV?” and switched on the TV. She stood there for some time starring at me and then walked away, because all my cousins and uncles came to watch the match. My aunt never gave me the explanation of why I shouldn’t switch on the TV. But the general message I think was that “You don’t watch TV, just a couple of days after someone has expired is the house.” I mean what kind of crap is that? I mean, isn’t it disgustingly funny??
3. No going out after dusk:
This is another “rule” that makes me laugh every time I think about it. This too happened a couple of days (Some 3-4 days.) after my father’s death. My friend had come to see me and said let’s go out, it will be a change for you. So I was starting to go out. Everyone was like “No, you can’t go out after dusk.” I laughed out aloud and asked “Why shouldn’t I go out after dusk?” The reply as usual was “You can’t gout that’s it.” and “Just listen to what we are saying. Don’t ask cross questions?” But, you all know me. I kept pressing everyone for an answer and not even one was able to come up with a proper answer.
I still am not able to understand the logic behind the “rule” that close relatives of a deceased person should not go out after dusk.
4. The Three Stones:
Now, to the main thing that inspired post and the tittle of the post.
What would you do if some guy brings you a stone and says this is your father/mother? You would, if not bash him up at least get into a verbal argument with him. Some of you would probably laugh. Right?? How many of you would do nothing about it and keep quiet??
Hindus have a final rites ritual, which happens about 10 days after a person dies. I did not want to do all these rituals. (One of the reasons being: Though he was a theist, my father never believed in rituals.) I was emotionally blackmailed into it. So, I accompanied my brother to the place where the ritual is to be performed. (It’s performed by some lake side.) I sit down and the guy who helps you do the rituals places three stones in front of me and says pointing to each stone in turn: “This is your father, your grandfather, your great grandfather!!!” I almost burst out laughing. I mean, come on people. Wouldn’t you find it funny if some guy/girl brought a stone and said this is my father/mother /grandfather/grandmother…. You would think “Poor thing, he/she has lost his/her marbles.” (Interestingly, marbles are also stones. Ha Ha Ha Ha!!!!)
I was supposed to do all kinds of poojas to the three stones, sorry to my forefathers. It was pathetic to say the least. What was more disgusting was the attitude of all my relatives who had accompanied us to do the ritual. They actually looked as I they took the whole “stones are your forefather” thing seriously. Judge for yourself people. I mean it is funny isn’t it? At least a tiny weenie bit??
5. Women are not allowed to perform the last rites:
Why is that we are in such a male chauvinistic society? Why is that women are still considered/treated as inferior to men? Why is that when a guy flirts/seduces many girls he called a playboy, a casanova and treated as a special person? Some people (Both guys and girls.) actually admire these guys and sort of place them on a pedestal. Whereas as when a girl flirts/seduces many boys, she’s called a slut, a whore and people treat her as a thing that is to be thrown to the dungeons?? Where is this diatribe leading to? Read on…
I have never been able to understand this aspect of Hindu society, not only are women are discriminated against in life but also in death. Women are not allowed to perform most of the rituals especially the last rites of a deceased person. C’mon, doesn’t a wife/mother/daughter/friend have as much right over the deceased person as a husband/father/son/friend? If you ask why women are not allowed, I am sure the answer to that will be: “Our forefathers did not allow it; they must have had some reason for it.” or “You should not question things like this.” I mean, no one, not a single person I am sure will come up with a rationale reason.
I am not saying one should not cry at a funeral. What I am saying is that, cry only if you feel like it. Second, learn to treat a person as more than just flesh and bones. A person is definitely more than that. Thirdly as J. K. Rowling speaks through her character Dumbledore asking a question; “Do you think our loved ones ever leave us?” The answer is of course a big NO. As mentioned earlier, our loved ones continue to live on in our memories, through their ideas and values. Fourth, try looking at life (your) objectively; you will realize a lot of things that you didn’t notice before.
2 comments:
Two things Hari!!! One, you have some very very valid points about the blind rituals and practices followed in Hinduism. YOu are also right when you say that people respect Flesh and Bones rather than the person in life. But the matter of fact is, once a loved one dies, we can no longer interact, feel, talk, or see the person. That itself is painfull da.
The second is that don't take everything at face value, not every custom is abided by blindly. When people cry in a funeral, not all people cry just for namesake,som people cry for the persons who were dependant on the dead person, some cry because they can no longer talk/ interact with the person, and some cry because they can no longer see/ interact with a person who would have been their best friend, partner, colleague etc.
Yes,you do have a point saying that our Loved ones never leave us even if they are dead. BUt such is the reality Hari, we have to also accept the fact that eventhough their memories are with us, we cannot withstand the grief of missing them. SOme feelings are unexplainable, don't try to reason them out, it is as good as asking a person why he is hungry?????
We are human beings, for heaven's sake, don't try to apply logic and atheism to every feeling and custom that you see. Somethings are best left as they are. Human emotions are far more tougher to comprehend. Let them be.
It is very surprising to see such a thought provoking question about a male chauvenistic society from a man. I wish all Indian men start thinking like you and understand women are equals rather treating them as god or glamour dolls. hats off to U Hari.
Janaki
Elementk
Post a Comment